Friday, March 6, 2009

My take on Delhi 6

by Tony Sebastian

I feel quite sorry for Rakeysh Omprakash Mehra. For someone who hates bollywood as much as I do, Delhi 6 was a welcome relief. Having been brought up on a steady diet of Sreenivasan at his satirical best, my movie appetite has long been starving for something like this which ROM dished out. The movie was entertaining, insightful, metaphorical and clever.

I am not here to review the movie. For one, I don't think I am qualified enough to do that and also Baradwaj Rangan has done a brilliant job of dissecting the movie here. Instead, I would like to put forth an analogy which will explain why I feel frustrated with people panning the movie...

I was pretty proud of the crossword which I had made. I was even gladder still that there were about 150 people gathered to solve it. I had taken great pains in ensuring that the clues were fair and clever. It had taken over three days to make the grid, but the effort was worth it. I handed out the sheets and the heads in the hall started bending down, I sat down with a contented smile on my face.

Five minutes later, I decided to walk around looking in to see how the solvers were doing. My heart sank when I saw people filling in "Guevara" for the clue "Does he instigate revolutions? (7)" I walked around and saw a few more of the same. The solvers had expected a quick crossword, I had prepared a cryptic crossword. They failed to see why "Does he instigate revolutions? (7)" would result in "SPINNER" or why that is beautiful. One by one, the people started leaving, they had had enough.

I think that in a nutshell sums up what happened with Delhi 6. He made a cryptic crossword, but the audience did not understand it. They were too used to the run-of-the-mill quick crossword and something as trivial as a symmetric grid was enough to win their appreciation. Anything smarter was given a miss.

If Delhi 6 is a cryptic crossword, its climax was the fit in clue - That one clue which you cannot frame properly. You don't really like it being part of the crossword, but you can't take it off since you need it to complete the grid. You hope that the solvers forgive you for that one clue because the rest of the crossword is good enough, and it is only fair that the one bad element is forgotten.

I realise that I sound extremely snobbish with that analogy, but I chose it only because it is one which I can relate to. I am sure this is how Vinu (my roomie and an ace musician) feels if he tries to explain to his musically dense friend (me) why a particular song is beautiful or Thomas (my other roomie) feels when I blink at him when he tells me how awesome his new graphics card is.

Delhi 6 was a perfect movie for the wrong audience. But I don't think the bollywood crowd is to be blamed. Malayalees eat beef because that is the way they have been brought up. The reason Delhi 6 is panned is because we are used to the senseless idiocy like "Singh is kinng" and "Om shanti om". I just hope that people like ROM don't feel disheartened and play to the galleries.

13 comments:

  1. I am definitely going to watch the movie now. :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. not everybody hated it. for starters, i thought it was pretty amazing :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. well, with all due respects to your cryptic crosswords and ROM, at times the complexity of message often ends up doing an injustice to its true meaning. I agree that Dilli 6 had many layers and hints to it, but none of them delved to a depth beyond the usual...and hence it left me, to use your oft quoted phrase 'partially satisfied' - if you want a message on communal divides and its impact watch parzania, if you want to look at the conflicting choices of an NRI watch swades, if you want a critique of our caste system see any of benegal's creations and if you want to critique the triviality of our media then Soha Ali Khan's story in Mumbai Meri Jaan beats everything else on that subject....
    my point being that simplicity has a virtue and complexity for the sake of it will miss its intended audience...not everyone will be able to penetrate beneath the layers...that too when there are so many of them competing for attention
    nice to see you turning serious...i would like to keep visiting this blog often...give me reasons to :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. @Malady
    Yes you should :)

    @YT
    and that is why you are my friend ;)

    @Affy
    I think it is wrong to say there is only one message in the movie. There are a lot of them.I felt they were put forth very subtly unlike the very obvious and almost jarring kala bandar towards the end.

    I hope to keep this blog busy :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. @tonay...ur reader group i'm sure would love the movie....coz even I have....mayb the part of the prob is that the subtle metamorphical layer ROM put forth in da first 2 hrs of the movie were never really understood by the other non appreciationg grp....wich left the in ur face climax sitting out like a sore thumb when it should only have been a minor mole on a otherwise very radiant face....Masakali made the world go round!!! Cheers to ur new blog.... For ppl who knew u fr nt more than one yr at coll n nt frm ur state like me r happy to c this...helps us to knoe u betr

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was gonna give the movie a miss, based merely on all the negative reviews it seems to have attracted. But I think I shall watch after all.

    ReplyDelete
  8. i agree with you. I was pretty impressed too. Om Shaanti Om and Singh is Kinng were much more popular in the US...they even reduced the ticket prices for this movie after a few days. :( atleast in MN they did..
    I like this blog. So excited for you!

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I loved the movie,and thought it was unfair that it was treated so badly. The ending was ok, but the message he tried to portray was profound. :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. @Ash
    Thanks for reading :)

    @Confuseis
    Go ahead and watch the movie :)

    @Rae
    yay! Thanks :D

    @Srav
    :) I wonder why we are best friends ;)

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Mehra is one person whom i want to thank on bended kneels for RDB.wen i saw the movie first i severly wished ,if i had had a chance to b the light boy ok girl atleast...then i can say ..i was a part of RDB..i was in awe for the director.i was dead sure that this muvi,dilli 6 is going to rock much before the trailors started to screen,simply the faith in som1 who gave us RDB.but see,hw things turned up..screw all those who cant digest,its their ignorance their lack of acceptibility !!

    ReplyDelete